This is exactly where my head is with this. My "catastrophe-preventing" brain is always seeking and aiming at these scenarios. It was the leading thought process that lead me to spending $10k-15k extra to buy a new truck v.s. a used one. At the time, that was the price difference. Sound examples of used LBZ trucks were being snatched up for $40k +/-, and then there was the gamble of getting one that had been abused. "Great... I saved $15k buying a used truck. But now I have to buy a new Allison 6-speed. Oh, and look, my injectors are going too!"
Why the 🤬 can't we get a good pickup truck anymore?! My '16 Tundra gave me ZERO heartburn in the 54k miles I owned it. One single visit to the dealership early on for a deformed hose nipple on the power steering fluid rez that was leaking. That's it. SOLID truck. Just a wimpy payload.
I hear ya, i don't like hearing of these issues either and I think it's a shock to the dmax owners because the previous true Allison was a great transmission. The fact is though that this is nothing new with GM, my first hd was a 16' 2500 but with the 6.0 and a 6l90. Well if you know about those they suffer torque converter failures that end up taking the whole trans out. I figured I would do 10k fluid intervals, baby the truck and I would not have this issue...55k miles into ownership trans down 3hr from home pulling my trailer. Those convertors were a known failure point in those and gm never did anything about it. So that's how I ended up going to the dmax because at the time the 6.6 gasser still had a 6l90 and I wasn't doing that again. Now I'm faced with another possibility of a known failure point within a GM transmission going out. Mine already suffered the front pump cover leak and had to be removed so I'm just waiting for the VB to strike.
Either way like others have said pick your poison, HD truck game has 3 players..GM, Ford and Ram and each have a known issues right now, Ford might be the one on top right now, then GM and then ram because of the lifter failures in the Cummins and up until the 25' model They didn't have a good transmission unless you went ho and got the aisin.
Yup I had a 2005 Tacoma that I drove for 10 years put over 120k miles on it, thing ran great…but it towed heavy loads like crap, and wasn’t comfortable towing for 7+hrs which I do. Now the Yotas are just as bad, recalls, etc…You name a brand of truck and I can show you problems, its become chose you poison.
I have a 2012 Taco that I bought new and still have, that's my daily driver. Solid truck, been so good to me and pretty much spoils you on what a vehicle should be. Maintenance and run it, but you are correct it's strong suit is not towing at all.