You're right in a sense that the Allison isn't bulletproof from the factory if you expect it to hold 600+hp. But honestly how many folks expect that? And yes its just another stock transmission. It does have some things most transmissions didn't when it came out in 2001. It was one of the only transmissions at the time to have the adaptive learning, as well as tow/haul mode. I don't think that Ford or Dodge had anything like that back in the early 2000's. Since then they've played catch-up to the Allison. The Allison is also a little better because it has limp mode to protect itself from damage. The Ford and 4 speed Dodge trannys don't. So you run a big tune and instead of hitting limp mode when it slips, you just keep your foot buried in it as the clutches melt away to nothing and after a few hard runs in a Dodge you have a tranny that wont go into a gear anymore. The soopr doopr awwwsum Ford transmissions are the same. Yes tuning will bump the line pressure up and they'll hold more power, but there's nothing from stopping the clutches from slipping. Too much power and they fail much like the Dodge will. The Allison protects itself so it'll keep on going after 50+ limps.
And like we've all said, it was designed to be behind a stock dmax, not a tuned one. And it is basically bulletproof behind a stock dmax. You almost can't kill one with stock tuning and even marginal maintenance. My lb7 has 220k on it and I tow all the time, and its got a 70hp tune on it. Not a single problem out of it.
There aren't many vehicles in the whole world that can take 200+hp and 3-400+tq over stock and not break something. Be happy you don't have a 46rh that dies with a whopping 160hp going through it like 2nd gen Dodge guys get to enjoy.
Does the Allison live up to the hype? I'd say it depends on the person. For the 99.9% of owners who leave their truck stock? I'd say it definitely does. For the 0.1% of us who push our trucks to the breaking point, its probably a wash. Some of us would say yes, some would say no.
Sent from my old skool Droid