First off, I posted this to 911 forum because I do not consider the truck as safe to drive on the highway or congested streets, but for some reason it does not show up on that forum. I am posting to this thread hoping it will post (since it will likely be moved to this thread anyways).
I have been battling an intermittent major electrical issue for a few months now and it seems to be getting worse. I purchased this truck from my brother a few years back and it has been a great truck up until recently. Let me try to break down the issues chronologically. I am not sure if these items are related but I wanted to mention them.
-Starting off- Around May 2018, I started to get "Service Trailer Brake System" on the DIC. I have been reading DM forums for a solution but the most common replaced part did not fix the issue (ACDelco 20904439 Trailer Brake Controller Module). This still happens from time to time mainly sitting at a red light during brake pedal movement (usually when brake is released) , which makes me think it is the brake pedal sensor as more time passes. I have not had time to have that changed out yet.
-Over summer I noticed that I was getting intermittent hard starts (cranking sounds weak, like using a weak battery). I had both 1 year old AGM batteries tested individually (they passed with flying colors), so I cleaned the terminals and put a fresh helping of battery terminal grease on the terminals. The issue never really got better but the truck never had a problem not starting at all. Some starts are amazing, more starts are just ok.
- Early August - Every once and a while the radio would reset the clock to 12:00, indicating to me that it lost enough power to reset the clock. This usually happened when I started the truck.
- August 14th - Local mechanic does an overall inspection and fluid service since truck turned 140k miles (changed brake, transmission & transfer case fluids at my request; replaced rear brakes & rotors; inspected belts & hoses; I asked him to look at alternator and batteries because of clock reset & harder starts - no issues found). I DIY the fuel filter change because it is super easy to do and I have done 2 others with no issues at all.
-Labor Day Weekend - While travelling back home at night on the interstate a few hours from home. The radio starts to crackle and the dash lights start flickering along with the headlights. This is especially noticeable when activating high beams or turning on a turn signal. I suspect it is the alternator, however during this fit of random flickering the dashboard shows 14+ voltage the entire time. I make it home on a wing and a prayer and take to my reliable mechanic after the holiday. His electrical guy spent 5 hours looking at everything and said that they could not find any issues. Since this issue is very intermittent, we could not replicate it. He felt bad that he couldnt find anything that he didnt charge me. It was fine for a few weeks until my next out of town trip (mentioned below).
- September 10th - "Water in Fuel -Service Required" - I just recently replaced my Fuel Filter myself a month earlier (1.5k miles ago). I read on this forum how to look into this error. I bled the filter and removed the sensor to find it was stuck in the up position. The fuel in the filter was captured in a mason jar and no water could be found. I put back together and I have seen the warning 2x since Sept 10th but they clear after the next start. Because I did a water inspection, I was not worried about water in the fuel. The problem has not appeared since Sept. 19th. I only mention this because I am wondering if an electrical issue could be causing this false positive.
- September 23rd @10am - I went out of town on the 21st and the 100 mile trek was fine. During the 21st, I pulled a 8k pound trailer and did at least a dozen start/stops of the engine and drove around short distances in the town I was in with no problem. September 23rd, I start up for the day around 10am to run an errand and within 2 minutes I had the worst episode so far. I was on a residential street and the radio goes dead for a few seconds (with loud pops over the speaker) and my dash lighting flickers. My accelerator pedal input was being ignored during this time, the engine was running but ramping down from about 3k RPM, (I still had power steering and brakes). About 2 seconds after this episode, I get power back and accelerator is responding again. I pull over to do an inspection and find nothing wrong. During this episode, I could see that the dash electrical meter was still above 14v the entire time. No other major issues to report during after that episode. I drive around the rest of the day with no issues (I made about 6 trips)
-September 23rd @ 8pm - I am travelling home from my weekend out of town on I-35 and get about 20 miles before I have another flickering episode. The dash lights start flickering with the headlights and the radio starts to crackle and the speakers start to pop as if the radio is losing power (like a voltage drop), but the voltage meter on the dash is reporting slightly above 14 volts. I swear I smell a burning smell, so I pull over at the next available exit to do another inspection under the hood and elsewhere. No burning smell and no evidence of any electrical fire. I have my hazards, headlights and dome lights on and I notice that the domes, headlights, and dash dim significantly when the hazards illuminate. I have a video of it that I will try to upload to youtube shortly. I take a voltage reading using a VOM and show it is reporting 14.55 volts at the actual battery terminals but showing regular dips down to 14.2 volts regularly (i assume because of the incandescent hazards). I decide to drive on the deserted interstate service road for a few miles to a rest stop a few miles away. During this time, everything was fine. After doing some more inspections, I decided to get back on the road. For the next 70 miles, there was not a single issue but as I got close to home, I had the flickering and radio problems again (not as bad as before but still happening). I get home and cannot replicate the issue.
So given all that, I want to get another inspection done but I want to walk in prepared to discuss the recent events to my mechanic to help narrow down the problem. I do not consider the truck safe and I will not let my wife pull her horse trailer with it until further notice. I am especially fearful of a complete electrical failure at highway speeds, which would cause engine to stop, power steering and brakes to fail as well. This scenario has not happened yet, but I feel that events have gotten progressively worse (especially with the loss of engine acceleration during the Sunday Morning episode).
The symptom seems to be fairly consistent when it happens: The entire truck components appears to have a severe voltage drop across all systems at random times even though electrical meters confirm the batteries have 14+ volts when the engine runs. These issues appear to come and go more often while the truck is in motion, however there are days/weeks that I have driven without any symptoms at all (I live in Dallas and we have some rough streets and that does not seem to jiggle anything loose).
Does anyone have any suggestions. I would greatly appreciate any and all suggestions.
I have been battling an intermittent major electrical issue for a few months now and it seems to be getting worse. I purchased this truck from my brother a few years back and it has been a great truck up until recently. Let me try to break down the issues chronologically. I am not sure if these items are related but I wanted to mention them.
-Starting off- Around May 2018, I started to get "Service Trailer Brake System" on the DIC. I have been reading DM forums for a solution but the most common replaced part did not fix the issue (ACDelco 20904439 Trailer Brake Controller Module). This still happens from time to time mainly sitting at a red light during brake pedal movement (usually when brake is released) , which makes me think it is the brake pedal sensor as more time passes. I have not had time to have that changed out yet.
-Over summer I noticed that I was getting intermittent hard starts (cranking sounds weak, like using a weak battery). I had both 1 year old AGM batteries tested individually (they passed with flying colors), so I cleaned the terminals and put a fresh helping of battery terminal grease on the terminals. The issue never really got better but the truck never had a problem not starting at all. Some starts are amazing, more starts are just ok.
- Early August - Every once and a while the radio would reset the clock to 12:00, indicating to me that it lost enough power to reset the clock. This usually happened when I started the truck.
- August 14th - Local mechanic does an overall inspection and fluid service since truck turned 140k miles (changed brake, transmission & transfer case fluids at my request; replaced rear brakes & rotors; inspected belts & hoses; I asked him to look at alternator and batteries because of clock reset & harder starts - no issues found). I DIY the fuel filter change because it is super easy to do and I have done 2 others with no issues at all.
-Labor Day Weekend - While travelling back home at night on the interstate a few hours from home. The radio starts to crackle and the dash lights start flickering along with the headlights. This is especially noticeable when activating high beams or turning on a turn signal. I suspect it is the alternator, however during this fit of random flickering the dashboard shows 14+ voltage the entire time. I make it home on a wing and a prayer and take to my reliable mechanic after the holiday. His electrical guy spent 5 hours looking at everything and said that they could not find any issues. Since this issue is very intermittent, we could not replicate it. He felt bad that he couldnt find anything that he didnt charge me. It was fine for a few weeks until my next out of town trip (mentioned below).
- September 10th - "Water in Fuel -Service Required" - I just recently replaced my Fuel Filter myself a month earlier (1.5k miles ago). I read on this forum how to look into this error. I bled the filter and removed the sensor to find it was stuck in the up position. The fuel in the filter was captured in a mason jar and no water could be found. I put back together and I have seen the warning 2x since Sept 10th but they clear after the next start. Because I did a water inspection, I was not worried about water in the fuel. The problem has not appeared since Sept. 19th. I only mention this because I am wondering if an electrical issue could be causing this false positive.
- September 23rd @10am - I went out of town on the 21st and the 100 mile trek was fine. During the 21st, I pulled a 8k pound trailer and did at least a dozen start/stops of the engine and drove around short distances in the town I was in with no problem. September 23rd, I start up for the day around 10am to run an errand and within 2 minutes I had the worst episode so far. I was on a residential street and the radio goes dead for a few seconds (with loud pops over the speaker) and my dash lighting flickers. My accelerator pedal input was being ignored during this time, the engine was running but ramping down from about 3k RPM, (I still had power steering and brakes). About 2 seconds after this episode, I get power back and accelerator is responding again. I pull over to do an inspection and find nothing wrong. During this episode, I could see that the dash electrical meter was still above 14v the entire time. No other major issues to report during after that episode. I drive around the rest of the day with no issues (I made about 6 trips)
-September 23rd @ 8pm - I am travelling home from my weekend out of town on I-35 and get about 20 miles before I have another flickering episode. The dash lights start flickering with the headlights and the radio starts to crackle and the speakers start to pop as if the radio is losing power (like a voltage drop), but the voltage meter on the dash is reporting slightly above 14 volts. I swear I smell a burning smell, so I pull over at the next available exit to do another inspection under the hood and elsewhere. No burning smell and no evidence of any electrical fire. I have my hazards, headlights and dome lights on and I notice that the domes, headlights, and dash dim significantly when the hazards illuminate. I have a video of it that I will try to upload to youtube shortly. I take a voltage reading using a VOM and show it is reporting 14.55 volts at the actual battery terminals but showing regular dips down to 14.2 volts regularly (i assume because of the incandescent hazards). I decide to drive on the deserted interstate service road for a few miles to a rest stop a few miles away. During this time, everything was fine. After doing some more inspections, I decided to get back on the road. For the next 70 miles, there was not a single issue but as I got close to home, I had the flickering and radio problems again (not as bad as before but still happening). I get home and cannot replicate the issue.
So given all that, I want to get another inspection done but I want to walk in prepared to discuss the recent events to my mechanic to help narrow down the problem. I do not consider the truck safe and I will not let my wife pull her horse trailer with it until further notice. I am especially fearful of a complete electrical failure at highway speeds, which would cause engine to stop, power steering and brakes to fail as well. This scenario has not happened yet, but I feel that events have gotten progressively worse (especially with the loss of engine acceleration during the Sunday Morning episode).
The symptom seems to be fairly consistent when it happens: The entire truck components appears to have a severe voltage drop across all systems at random times even though electrical meters confirm the batteries have 14+ volts when the engine runs. These issues appear to come and go more often while the truck is in motion, however there are days/weeks that I have driven without any symptoms at all (I live in Dallas and we have some rough streets and that does not seem to jiggle anything loose).
Does anyone have any suggestions. I would greatly appreciate any and all suggestions.